Carly Smithson
Crazy on You
Amanda Overmyer must be pissed that Carly beat her to this Heart classic. The most professional-sounding — and most actually professional — of the girls brings the pipes and some serious energy to this song, baring her tattoos and bouncing on stage in a way that must make Fox censors hope she's employing two-sided tape. She's certainly powerful enough for the rocker, though her controlled voice lacks the, well, craziness that would have taken it over the top. Easily good enough to keep her around, though.